Satisfactory patient-reported outcomes at 5 years following primary repair with suture tape augmentation for proximal anterior cruciate ligament tears
Authors: Graeme P. Hopper, Joanna M. S. Aithie, Joanne M. Jenkins, William T. Wilson, Gordon M. Mackay
Journal: Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy
Publication year: 2022
DOI: 10.1007/s00167-021-06485-z
IBISG Summary
This prospective study reports minimum five-year outcomes following primary ACL repair with suture tape augmentation for acute proximal tears. Thirty-seven consecutive patients were enrolled, with 34 available for the final analysis. Patients with midsubstance or distal tears, poor tissue quality, retracted ligament remnants or multi-ligament injuries were excluded.
Key Findings
Twenty-eight of the 34 patients available at five years had satisfactory outcomes without re-rupture. Mean KOOS improved from 48.7 before surgery to 88.5 at five years, while pain and physical health scores also improved significantly. Six patients experienced a re-rupture, producing a failure rate of 17.6%. These patients were significantly younger and had higher initial activity scores. All six underwent revision ACL reconstruction without subsequent reported problems.
Why This Research Matters
This study provides valuable longer-term evidence that augmented primary ACL repair can produce sustained improvements in carefully selected patients with proximal tears. It also highlights an important re-rupture risk among younger and more active patients, reinforcing the need for appropriate patient selection and informed discussion of treatment options. Because this was an uncontrolled Level IV study, it does not establish that repair is superior or equivalent to ACL reconstruction.